June 19, 2017, 2:04 pm

Outfit Items: View
Description:
Avatars & Skin
AvatarSkin
![]()
Colin.
Skin Demon
by
Balor
by
WllLoki
![]()
333
663
Head & Face
HairEyebrows
Eyes
Head
Head
![]()
. YUMO BLUNT FAD
Eyebrows Loyalty
Colorful eye
!T! Head Resizer
Head Loki 2017
by
TLMM
by
eWR3CKD
by
WllLoki
by
ChicByTrinity
by
WllLoki
![]()
775
443
554
397
704
Clothes
TopBottom
Shoes
![]()
t-Shert Monkey B
Pants Loki
Boots Black & Re
by
WllLoki
by
WllLoki
by
WllLoki
![]()
719
652
697
Accessories
GlovesScaler
Scaler
Scaler
Lip Rings
Miscellaneous
![]()
++SMALL HANDS++
Hand Scaler
Legs Scaler
Arm Scaler
Lip Rings Black
Band Hello Kitty
by
sadoOoZ
by
Scaler
by
Scaler
by
Scaler
by
WllLoki
by
WllLoki
![]()
558
698
698
698
641
742
Necklaces
Hats
![]()
Necklaces Initia
Hat Snap Demon
by
WllLoki
by
WllLoki
![]()
669
718


Edited 864 time(s). Last edit at 07/13/2017 10:15AM by Guest_SedulityGrader15.
June 20, 2017, 10:03 am
I think you did fairly well on the proportions regarding the body, but the head is too small. 110-115% might make it look better in that regard. Of course, you could also go with 105% arm scalers and a smaller leg scaler. We normally don't scale arms or legs unless we feel like it's necessary because these outfits are uploaded on the site for the general public. People who choose to use them are free to add their own scalers. Otherwise, it's just an additional cost and a personal preference of your own. --And I just noticed that your hands are too small for the arms, so you'll need to scale those up as well. But like I said, you could also remove the scalers for your submissions.
Now, I hope you can handle critiquing regarding your own products. Nothing is intended to offend you, but I have to point out that the shoes don't seem to have any texture to them besides on the strings. The shirt is more or less the same. I've done this too, but you made the black texture so dark that it's hard to see any texture...if I turn my screen up and down, then I can see some remnants of wrinkles and texture on the back of the top, but the front looks completely black. The top also glitches with the belt of the bottoms, so it might be a better idea to change it to a mesh that won't glitch.
As far as the accessories go, I like the piercings and necklace. The hat is a nice addition, even though the red doesn't match the other shades used for the shoes and belt. The band-aid is, of course, really random among everything else. I like to think that you were being humorous when you added it because he looks so "bad-ass" until you notice that small detail. But instead, I think you could have tossed in a wrist accessory.
Lastly, just make sure that you title your submissions correctly. Read the rules in case you haven't, too. But this is a bundle, so the title should be: Awaiting Submission [Bundle]
I'm editing the title to fix that for you this time. But anyway, both the shoes and top are the big issues here, but only one can be changed (see resub rules), so I'm not sure how well a resub will turn out. I'll leave it to you and look forward to seeing how this turns out unless other judges feel differently.
B+
Now, I hope you can handle critiquing regarding your own products. Nothing is intended to offend you, but I have to point out that the shoes don't seem to have any texture to them besides on the strings. The shirt is more or less the same. I've done this too, but you made the black texture so dark that it's hard to see any texture...if I turn my screen up and down, then I can see some remnants of wrinkles and texture on the back of the top, but the front looks completely black. The top also glitches with the belt of the bottoms, so it might be a better idea to change it to a mesh that won't glitch.
As far as the accessories go, I like the piercings and necklace. The hat is a nice addition, even though the red doesn't match the other shades used for the shoes and belt. The band-aid is, of course, really random among everything else. I like to think that you were being humorous when you added it because he looks so "bad-ass" until you notice that small detail. But instead, I think you could have tossed in a wrist accessory.
Lastly, just make sure that you title your submissions correctly. Read the rules in case you haven't, too. But this is a bundle, so the title should be: Awaiting Submission [Bundle]
I'm editing the title to fix that for you this time. But anyway, both the shoes and top are the big issues here, but only one can be changed (see resub rules), so I'm not sure how well a resub will turn out. I'll leave it to you and look forward to seeing how this turns out unless other judges feel differently.
B+
June 20, 2017, 12:55 pm
Mod Edit: Ensure you follow the rules. You cannot post a resub until a final grade is posted and a mod messages you telling you that a resub has been granted.
June 25, 2017, 2:28 pm
I agree with iMoo. I don't think the shirt is needed here? You didn't include it in any of the photos, making people having to try on the outfit to see that there is a shirt. If you want the shirt, I think you should include it in every picture, otherwise it's misleading. On Sedulity, the shirt will be included, where as here, it's not. So I'm not sure if you're wanting the shirt or not.
The band-aid is really random, it's pink but everything else is red and black. Also, I think the hands are too small here, and it might be the avi?
B+
The band-aid is really random, it's pink but everything else is red and black. Also, I think the hands are too small here, and it might be the avi?
B+
June 30, 2017, 12:32 pm
It's against the rules to edit your submission to change pictures or any of the submission code once it has been graded/critiqued. The only thing you can do is add or change the description. I believe this included the top in the pictures when I graded, so just letting you know.
July 3, 2017, 7:38 pm
Agree with all above
Besides what was pointed out, you really need to go back and make sure you understand and follow the rules, especially resub rules so you can successfully do a resub of your outfit and avoid another failure due to broken rules
B+
Besides what was pointed out, you really need to go back and make sure you understand and follow the rules, especially resub rules so you can successfully do a resub of your outfit and avoid another failure due to broken rules
B+
July 3, 2017, 7:45 pm

B+
88.33 %
3 judges have voted, the judge average was 88.33 % ( B+ )
Grading Breakdown:
| B+ : iMoo         : Judge | | B+ : EmeraldLagoon : Judge | | B+ : LYDIANN16    : Judge |
July 7, 2017, 2:45 am

Outfit Items: View
Description:
Avatars & Skin
AvatarSkin
Skin
Skin
![]()
Jerry.
Hipster Arm Tatt
Skin Marcel
Tattoo Demon Win
by
Balor
by
Baler
by
WllLoki
by
WllLoki
![]()
663
798
718
688
Head & Face
HairEyebrows
Eyes
Head
Head
![]()
Abel Militar
- I'm bulletpro
Colorful eye
!T! Head Resizer
Head Loki 2017
by
Polynesia
by
Lights
by
WllLoki
by
ChicByTrinity
by
WllLoki
![]()
774
608
554
397
704
Clothes
TopTop
Bottom
Shoes
![]()
Z ~~ Leather jac
Perfect Real BOD
Pants Loki
Nike Air Force B
by
Stattion
by
golos206x
by
WllLoki
by
Banked
![]()
664
445
652
663
Accessories
ActionsScaler
Ear Plugs
Gloves
Watches
Glasses Kings
![]()
Hand Resizer
Legs Scaler
Red Ear Plugs
[PL] FiGht HandW
Golden Watch
Skull Hat Snap
by
Scaler
by
Scaler
by
Baller
by
PLEDGEDLIFE
by
iJAM
by
WllLoki
![]()
698
698
641
579
597
718
Lip Rings
1st True New H
![]()
Lip Ring black s
Brow Spikes Pier
by
WllLoki
by
WllLoki
![]()
608
619



July 13, 2017, 10:10 am
This breaks a rule.
You are only allowed to change one clothing item from the original submission. You changed both the pants and the top
F
You are only allowed to change one clothing item from the original submission. You changed both the pants and the top
F
July 13, 2017, 10:15 am

F
50 %
1 judge have voted, the judge average was 50 % ( F )
Grading Breakdown:
| FÂ : EmeraldLagoon : Judge |
Note: This submission was declined early;
This submission has broken a rule listed at [www.imvu.com].
You must message staff to be granted a resub.